Edit ModuleShow Tags

Citizen’s Arrest

Can you? Should you?


Citizen's arrest- you've probably heard the expression. You've probably even had the urge to slap some cuffs on that neighborhood kid with the incessantly blaring boombox. But is this really possible? Are you legally allowed to stop a crime in progress?

Yes, you are, although arresting someone for a noise violation may be a bit much. According to the Hawai'i Revised Statutes, section 803-3, "Anyone in the act of committing a crime may be arrested by any person present without a warrant." The law also permits the use of force in the arrest, according to Jim Fulton, spokesperson for the Honolulu city prosecutor's office. After arresting someone, though, you are required to promptly turn over the suspect to the police-no instant justice, no overnight detentions.

Citizens' arrests do occur, if rarely. In 2000, an O'ahu homeowner placed a citizens' arrest-and a headlock-on a man he found stealing avocados from his back yard. He got a lesson in the risks of law enforcement, though, when the collared ne'er-do-well sicced his pitbull on the homeowner, resulting in minor wounds before police arrived. On the upside, the avocados were successfully protected.

Illustration: Mike Austin

More common are citizens' arrests made by store detectives and hotel security guards, who, despite their official-looking uniforms and shiny badges, have no more arrest authority than the rest of us. Warren Ferreira, corporate director of security for the Outrigger Hotels, says his security officers are authorized to arrest suspects on hotel property. "We can't duck [arresting someone] in a trespass situation, because we're the front line. We generally try to detain without physical force, and then have the police officer make the arrest."

But most security firms shy away from arresting suspicious characters, for fear of lawsuits. John Tavares of Star Protection Agency Inc. says, "As security officers, our role is to deter criminal activity by our presence, and then observe and report. We do not permit our employees to perform citizens' arrests. There's too much liability."

What about Dog Chapman, the bounty hunter who seems to be handcuffing people regularly? Like security guards, bounty hunters and bail-enforcement agents have the same rights as average citizens, plus a vaguely implied right of arrest under section 804-14 of the HRS, which states that a person who has posted bail for a defendant "may at any time discharge themselves by surrendering him to the custody of any sheriff or chief of police or his authorized subordinate."

Arrest is not always the first choice for bondsmen, Chapman notwithstanding. James Lindblad, owner of A-1 Bail Bonds, says, "I wouldn't walk across the street to pick somebody up. We tell the indemnitor that they need to turn them in." (For those readers lucky enough to be ignorant of bail-bond terminology, an indemnitor posts collateral and co-signs the bond for someone out on bail.)

The Honolulu Police Department's official line on citizen's arrest? No comment. Brandon Stone, HPD spokesperson, says, "If we say anything at all about this, we tell people, hey, call 911. Be careful, don't get hurt."

Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module

Subscribe to Honolulu

Honolulu Magazine October 2018
Edit ModuleShow Tags



41 Thoughts We Had While Watching the New “Magnum P.I.”

Magnum PI

Only one mentions Jay Hernandez's shirt.


20 Great O‘ahu Hikes

20 Great Hikes

20 great adventures that offer beautiful vistas, waterfalls, steep climbs and relics of the past.


16 Fascinating Facts About Sharks in Hawai‘i Every Local Should Know


Important facts you may not know about sharks in Hawai‘i.


50 Greatest Songs of Hawai‘i

50 Greatest Songs

An esteemed panel of musicologists, producers and artists select the greatest hits in Hawai‘i’s music history.


Political Survivor

Mazie Hirono

A Closer Look at Hawaiʻi’s First Female Senator, Mazie Hirono.

Edit ModuleShow Tags