Edit ModuleShow Tags

Clipping Service



Published:

The Akaka bill, which would allow Native Hawaiians to form their own government, became a high-profile piece of legislation in the U.S. Senate this year. Here are two opposing viewpoints we found, showing the range of Mainland reaction.

A July 12 editorial in The New York Times by Lawrence Downes was entitled, "In Hawai'i, a chance to Heal, Long Delayed."
The spirit of aloha, of gentle welcome, is the direct legacy of native culture and an incalculable gift the Hawaiian people have made to everyone who has ever traveled there-wobbly-legged sailors and missionaries, dogged immigrants and sun-scorched tourists. The Akaka bill, with its first steps at long-deferred Hawaiian self-determination, seems like an obvious thing to give in return, an overdue measure of simple gratitude.

Ramesh Ponnuru of the National Review, however, called his July 18 article, "Hawai'i wants a segregation that would boggle your mind."
Native Hawaiians aren't a separate and distinct community. They aren't geographically separate. ... Nor have Native Hawaiians exercised political sovereignty. There are no pretenders to the old Hawaiian throne. There wasn't a purely race-based government in Hawai'i even before 1893. The queen had subjects who had come, or whose ancestors had come, to Hawai'i from all over the world. The government included officials of many races. ...

Jon Kyl, a Republican senator from Arizona, has led the opposition to the bill.
"It is the antithesis of the American concept of E pluribus unum and could begin the Balkanization of the United States based strictly on race and ethnicity."

Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module

Subscribe to Honolulu

Honolulu Magazine September 2018
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Trending

 

Remembering Anthony Bourdain, Who Helped Share the Stories of Hawai‘i

Anthony Bourdain

The chef, writer and TV host filmed episodes of "No Reservations" and "Parts Unknown" in the Islands.

 

7 Iconic Sugar Mill Smokestacks That Still Stand Tall in Hawai‘i

Smokestacks Sugar Mill Ladd

The landmark smokestacks serve as daily reminders of these communities’ rich plantation history.

 

Hawaiʻi Summer 2018 Bon Dance Schedule

Obon Festival Moiliili

Obon season is here, time to dance!

 

The Ultimate “Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom” Drinking Game

Jurassic World

The filmed-in-Hawai‘i sequel to 2015’s summer blockbuster premieres June 22.

Edit ModuleShow Tags